Evolution of the Mind and Dücane Cündioğlu
- okukitap.net
- Sep 17, 2023
- 7 min read
In short, we have before us a humanoid who is mindless, has no knowledge of military service, has zero knowledge of literature, but is a chatterbox. You cannot argue with foolish people; The area it pulls you into is literally insane. These are word acrobats, you can't beat them, you can only expose them.
“Does a person need any teacher to believe in the creator, who is a necessary being?” If there was a need for a tutorial on this subject, we could say that a tutorial would also be needed to understand what this tutorial is talking about, and we could extend this indefinitely. This situation leads to the denial of the human ability to acquire basic knowledge, that is, the mind. Because reason is the power that knows the necessities and impossibilities as "subject to".
In a video on the internet, Dücane Cündioğlu, without understanding the nature of the mind; He claims that people who believe in God believe without thinking, saying, "Well, many people who have never thought throughout their lives believe in God (a necessary being) and their faith is never shaken." However, you cannot believe in God without thinking. From the point of view of reason, knowledge of necessity is a natural knowledge and you can only deny this knowledge out of stubbornness. For this reason, although Islam did not approve of imitation of faith, it accepted it as valid. Those who do not accept necessary existence, even though they are intelligent, actually deny rational principles. Ducane is chattering away; He doesn't use his mind but works his mouth.
Since Ducane does not understand the mind and its functions, he claims that the religious provisions regarding worship were made up to prevent thinking: “The best part of being a society is not to think. Worship exists to prevent thinking. Thinking is a virus that damages the sense of sociality.” If Dücane has a family (sociality), it means that he comes together with his family without thinking, like an animal. He gives an example from the military: "In the military, you do not think, because if you think, you cannot obey." However, military obedience is “conscious obedience.” Otherwise, you cannot win any war you engage in with animals. Dücane also says this as if he understands literature; “Poetry is an obstacle to thinking, the tool of thinking is prose.” The reference here is the verses saying "we heard and obeyed". In short, we have before us a humanoid who is mindless, has no knowledge of military service, has zero knowledge of literature, but is a chatterbox. You cannot argue with foolish people; The area it pulls you into is literally insane. These are word acrobats, you can't beat them, you can only expose them.
He loves the premise of “thinking for the sake of thinking.” He is unaware that thought that is "disconnected" with reality and truth will create a vortex, and more importantly, he is unaware that thinking is the ladder to reach transcendental things. He has no intention of getting out of the pus-filled well he fell into; He loves to "play with his own shit" with sterile logical fictions. Now everything is possible, everything is impossible, everything exists, nothing exists. Once you escape the consequences of reasoning, the result is obvious: Insanity. Because the word "aql" literally means "to bind". He also objects to this: He has the attitude of "I don't keep my mind tied to one place." “Don't be afraid, my dear. "You don't tie your mind to somewhere, you connect to your mind." If you do not connect to the mind; You are thrown from side to side in constantly changing emotions. It is a mental necessity to connect to the mind that naturally knows the necessities and impossibilities. Because necessity and impossibility are the final point of attachment. Not connecting to reason will cause you to anchor in mindlessness.
In his 4-hour chatter, Dücane thinks it is a skill to attack the truth that "There is no question about God's wisdom". However, wisdom is not something separate from God; Allah is inherently wise. When the mind becomes aware of the necessary existence, those who try to overcome the wall of necessity lose their minds. “The one who created where is not asked where, and the one who created how is not asked how.” Those who question God's wisdom always lose. Let's give an example from Dücane's fallacy teacher, Satan. Iblis responded to Allah's command to "prostrate before Adam" by saying, "You created me from fire and him from soil, I am superior to him." It does not know earth, it does not know fire, but it is airy. He lost his position; His new duty is to deceive people just like Dücane. Then... What follows is eternal hell. Loss after loss.
Cündioğlu brings up the evolution of the mind under the title "Evolution of Reason" and markets the concept of "primitive man". He mentions two elements for the emergence of the mind: The existence of money and writing.
All legal systems, states, religions and social systems in the world are built on the acceptance that reason requires responsibility. This responsibility is accepted perfectly and equally for all people. Again, all legal systems, states, religions and social systems have agreed that those who are not rational will not be responsible. Therefore, reason is binding on the person. In order for reason to be absolutely binding, it must not increase or decrease, be perfect in itself, and the accuracy of the judgments it makes cannot be disputed. The concept of a little mind is meaningless in terms of the binding nature of the mind. If we are talking about a mind that changes from person to person, it is not possible to establish an objective legal order.
Could there be anyone more pathetic than the person who thinks that his intelligence increases as his money increases? He tells stories, lies coldly, and hides his identity by playing the role of a pedantic thinking animal. By looking at it with the magnificence of reason, we know of course that He is infinitely foolish. If the mind is not perfect, we must not trust any of our perceptions. Looking at the issue from this perspective, people who talk about the theory of evolution should at least be able to say, in terms of logical consistency, "Nothing we say can be proven true. We are reading stories. Our statements are nonsense."
If you put your mind aside; You build obligations from possibles. He gets caught up in the fluid state of emotions, is deceived by the magic of aphorisms, is crushed in the pressure of daily life, clings to rootless branches while being thrown from place to place, falls into the sea and hugs a snake, idolizes things for stability, does not even realize his existence, thinks that he will be happy by imitating an animal, his heart becomes narrow, everything turns into a mirage. He creates fictions that conflict with truth and reality through logic games, poses thinking, thinking that his own cave is the truth, but at that very moment death comes and shatters everything. Before reading the Quran, we seek refuge in Allah from the devil, but this is one of those devils: Ducane.
Dücane, who got caught up in the fallacy "If there is thought, there is no belief, if there is belief, there is no thought"; He thinks he has found something by asking the question "Why does God not have the attribute of reason?" He claims that the word "reason" is unknown in the Quran, that the act of "reasoning" that he brought up is not a sublime act, that the real sublimity is thinking for the sake of thinking, and thinks that asking all kinds of absurd questions and determinations is mental freedom. Implicitly; “I am not bound by the necessary conclusions reached by reason. "If I determine that the universe had a beginning, the natural consequence of this determination, that the universe was created, does not concern me," he says. This is magnificent foolishness. However, belief is the definitive conclusion reached by someone who sets his mind free. His view of the mind is nihilistic and he guards the mind so that it does not escape to the truth. The act of "thought for thought's sake" has no functional meaning, moreover, this action is swimming in the sea of fraud. I heard him on a TV program... He was once giving a course on tafsir, and at that time, just like today, he did not believe in the eternity of hell, but he did not say these ideas just to avoid reaction. It is not even possible to say that the owner of these sentences has morals, let alone his mind. Who knows what he is saying without belief now? What would you expect from someone who is proud of being a non-believer?
A believer has nothing to do with thoughts. However, is it possible for a person who frees his mind to freeze his thoughts? Faith is the name of believing in the results reached by the mind. Where your mind takes you means certainty, and so if you don't believe with your mind, you don't actually believe. If the mind is not a measure, even if you go up to the skies and even see heaven and hell, you can say "my eyes are fascinated". You cannot think and believe with your feelings. Ducane; He is nothing more than someone who invents useless issues for himself so that "my mind does not accidentally escape to the truth".
Lies are worth a lot of money. He tells the lie without blushing that "Anyone who returns from Islam will be destroyed along with his family according to Islam." However, in Islam, the individuality of the crime is essential. Morality is really minus 10. He also talks about heaven, which he doesn't believe in. Because he claims that there is no mental reward in heaven. However, heaven is a place where the mind is not crushed by necessity. It is a wonderful place of will and self. For example, those who will go to heaven will look at Dücane, who will go to hell, while he is in fire; He will laugh and will never be sad that he will remain thirsty forever. Because the mind will definitely know that Dücane deserves eternal hell. In addition, Muslims will see Allah in heaven, which is the peak of mental pleasure. Ibn Abidin says: "Two worships that exist on earth will continue in Heaven: Faith and Marriage." Faith refers to mental pleasures in heaven, and marriage refers to physical pleasures. Those who despise physical pleasures have lost their minds.
As for Dücane's audacity to give the adjective of reason to God... God describes himself as "Lord of the world" in his own book. Since the word "Alem" refers to intelligent beings, the word "Rabb'ul 'Alemin" means "Allah is the master of intelligent beings." Allah is the creator of the mind and is above the mind. Man reaches the truth through reasoning. Oh God... Will God, who is God Himself, reach the truth through reason... There is no need to take Dücane seriously. There is no interpretation of nonsense.
Why do we seek refuge in Allah from Satan? Are Satan's traps too strong? Logic traps are too complicated. Of course no. On the contrary, the devil attacks with irrationality. That's why you can't mess with it. You have only one solution: To seek refuge in Allah from Him. You can't deal with reasoning, you can't interpret nonsense.
Comments